Sheetz Menu Prices – When you think of quick bites, road trip fuel, or a late-night snack run, one name almost always pops into mind—Sheetz. Over the years, Sheetz has become more than just a gas station convenience store. It’s a food destination. With its famous Made-to-Order (MTO) menu, endless drink options, and snacks you can’t resist, Sheetz has built a cult following across the United States.
But let’s be honest—one question always lingers in everyone’s mind: How much will it cost me?
In this guide, we’re breaking down the Sheetz menu prices for 2025, covering food, drinks, and snacks in detail. Whether you’re planning your first Sheetz visit or you’re a regular customer trying to compare costs, this breakdown will give you everything you need to know.
🥗 Sheetz Made-to-Order (MTO) Menu Prices
The MTO menu is the crown jewel of Sheetz. Here, you can customize just about anything—burgers, salads, wraps, quesadillas, and more. Sheetz Menu Prices vary based on size, toppings, and extras, but here’s a look at some popular 2025 choices:
| Item | Starting Price | Calories (Base) |
|---|---|---|
| Made To Order Salad | $8.39 | 22 Cals |
| Crispy Chicken Salad | $10.69 | 298 Cals |
| Grilled Chicken Salad | $10.69 | 117 Cals |
| Steak Salad | $9.59 | 89 Cals |
| Italian Sub | $6.99 | 350 Cals |
| Custom MTO Burger | $7.49 | 420 Cals |
💡 Personal Note: If you’ve never tried the Grilled Chicken Salad, it’s worth it. Light, filling, and customizable with toppings like guacamole or jalapeños.
👉 You can check out our full Sheetz MTO Salad Menu for detailed breakdowns.
🍔 Sheetz Burger & Sandwich Menu Prices
Nothing beats a juicy burger at midnight, and Sheetz delivers. The best part? You can add extras like bacon, fried egg, or Boom Boom sauce to make it your own.
- Made-to-Order Burger – starting at $7.49
- Crispy Chicken Sandwich – around $6.99
- Spicy Chicken Sandwich – about $7.29
- Club Sandwich – $6.59
💡 If you’re a fan of fast food, Sheetz burgers compete directly with McDonald’s and Burger King. They’re usually a little more customizable but often cheaper depending on add-ons.
👉 For a full burger-focused breakdown, check our Sheetz Made-to-Order Burger Menu.
🌮 Sheetz Snack Wraps, Tacos, and Quesadillas
If you’re craving something handheld and quick, Sheetz offers snack wraps, tacos, and quesadillas—all at affordable prices.
- Snack Wraps – starting at $2.99
- Quesadillas – around $6.99
- Taco Salads – starting from $8.39
💡 Personal Pick: The Steak Quesadilla with Boom Boom sauce hits differently—warm, cheesy, and packed with flavor.
🍟 Sheetz Appetizers & Sides
This is where Sheetz gets fun. Their Appetizerz menu has everything from fries to mozzarella sticks. Perfect for sharing… or not.
| Item | Price Range | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Fryz (Regular) | $2.59 | 365 Cals |
| Mozzarella Sticks | $3.99 | 390 Cals |
| Onion Rings | $3.49 | 420 Cals |
| Jalapeño Poppers | $3.99 | 450 Cals |
| Mac & Cheese Bites | $4.29 | 470 Cals |
💡 Late-night cravings? Order a large Fryz with Boom Boom dipping sauce. It’s a Sheetz classic.
👉 Explore our Sheetz Appetizers Menu for more side options.
🥤 Sheetz Drink Prices (Coffee, Shakes & More)
Sheetz isn’t just about food—it’s also a drink destination. Whether you’re a coffee lover, a smoothie fan, or someone craving a shake, Sheetz has it all.
- Fresh Brewed Coffee – starting at $1.89
- Espresso Drinks – around $3.59
- Smoothies – $4.99
- Milkshakes – $5.49+
Read Full menu of Sheetz Drinks.
🍩 Sheetz Bakery & Breakfast Prices
Morning or midnight—Sheetz bakery and breakfast items are always available.
- Donuts – starting at $1.19
- Bagels with Cream Cheese – $2.49
- Breakfast Sandwiches – $3.99–$5.99
- Cinnamon Rolls – $2.99
💡 Question I get a lot: Does Sheetz have bagels? Yes, and they’re fresh, affordable, and go perfectly with Sheetz coffee.
🥤 Sheetz Beverages & Everyday Items
Unlike fast-food chains, Sheetz doubles as a convenience store. That means you can grab basics like:
- Milk – around $3.29 per gallon
- Bananas – usually $0.59 each
- Bottled Water & Soda – $1.99–$2.49
💡 This makes Sheetz a practical stop if you’re road-tripping or just need grocery basics late at night.
✅ Why Sheetz Menu Prices Stand Out in 2025
So, is Sheetz cheaper than traditional fast-food chains? The answer is yes and no.
- Cheaper: Many snack items, salads, and basic burgers are more affordable than McDonald’s or Burger King.
- More Value: Sheetz gives you bigger portions and more customization.
- More Variety: Beyond fast food, you can grab snacks, groceries, and even fresh fruit.
👉 You can read our deep dive: Is Sheetz Cheaper Than Fast Food Chains Like McDonald’s?.
Ready to order? Order Now at Sheetz.
🔎 FAQs About Sheetz Menu Prices 2025
1. Are Sheetz menu prices the same everywhere?
No, prices may vary slightly by location, but the difference is usually small.
2. Is Sheetz more expensive than McDonald’s?
For basics, it’s similar. But Sheetz offers more customization at slightly higher prices.
3. Does Sheetz sell healthy options?
Yes, check out their Healthy Menu with salads, wraps, and fruit.
4. Can I order Sheetz food online?
Yes, via the Sheetz app or third-party delivery apps like DoorDash.
5. What’s the cheapest thing on the Sheetz menu?
Snack wraps, starting around $2.99, are among the cheapest.
6. Does Sheetz sell groceries like milk and fruit?
Yes, Sheetz offers basics like milk, bananas, and even bread.
Final Thoughts
The Sheetz Menu Prices 2025 offer a balance of affordability and variety. Whether you’re grabbing a quick coffee, building a custom MTO burger, or indulging in a milkshake, Sheetz continues to deliver value for money.
With so many options under one roof, it’s no wonder Sheetz has become more than just a pit stop—it’s a food experience.
👉 Ready to explore more? Check out our Sheetz Menu Blog for in-depth breakdowns of salads, appetizers, and drinks.
Leave a Reply