If you think Sheetz is only about gas and made-to-order meals, you’re missing one of its biggest hidden gems — the Sheetz Bakery Menu. Packed with fresh cookies, brownies, donut holes, muffins, cupcakes, pretzels, and premium packaged desserts, Sheetz bakery items are perfect for snacking, dessert cravings, breakfast-on-the-go, and late-night treats.
In this complete and up-to-date guide, we break down the Sheetz bakery menu with prices, calories (where available), best picks, and value tips — all in an easy-to-read, SEO-friendly format.
🧁 What Is the Sheetz Bakery Menu?
The Sheetz bakery menu includes:
- Shweetz® in-house bakery items
- Branded desserts (Cinnabon, Killer Brownie, Nemo’s, David’s, Rip Van Wafels)
- Fresh muffins, donut holes, cookies, brownies, cake pops, and pretzels
- Individually wrapped convenience bakery snacks
Most items are ready-to-go, making them ideal for:
- Breakfast stops
- Coffee pairings
- Road trips
- After-meal desserts
- Late-night cravings
🍪 Sheetz Shweetz Gourmet Cookies – Prices & Calories
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Shweetz Gourmet B-DAY Sh’prinklez Cookie | $2.50 | — |
| Shweetz Gourmet Chocolate Rainbow Crunch Cookie | $2.50 | — |
| Shweetz Peanut Butter Cheesecake Fudge Cookie | $2.50 | — |
| Shweetz Gourmet Chocolate Chip Cookie | $2.50 | 470 |
| Shweetz White Chocolate Macadamia Cookie | $2.50 | 490 |
Why they’re popular:
These oversized gourmet cookies are soft, rich, and bakery-style, competing with standalone cookie shops at a fraction of the price.
Also check out:
🍩 Sheetz Donut Holes Menu (Shweetz Cups)
| Donut Holes Flavor | Price |
|---|---|
| Birthday Cake Donut Holes Cup | $4.39 |
| Blueberry Donut Holes Cup | $4.39 |
| Chocolate Donut Holes Cup | $4.39 |
| Red Velvet Donut Holes Cup | $4.39 |
| Strawberry Donut Holes Cup | $4.39 |
| Glazed Donut Holes Cup | $4.39 |
Best for: Sharing, parties, or sweet cravings on road trips.
🍰 Sheetz Muffins & Breakfast Bakery Items
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Shweetz Blueberry Muffin | $3.39 | — |
| Shweetz Cinnabon Muffin | $3.39 | — |
| MTgo! Soft Pretzel | $1.29 | 290 |
💡 Pro tip: Pair muffins with Sheetz coffee for a budget breakfast combo.
🍫 Brownies, Crispy Treats & No-Bake Desserts
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Shweetz Brownie Bites Cup (3.75oz) | $4.39 | 440 |
| Plain Crispy Bites Cup | $4.39 | — |
| Chocolate PB Crispy Bites Cup | $4.39 | — |
| Tutti Frutti Crispy Bites Cup | $4.39 | — |
| Shweetz No-Bake Nubbins Cup (7oz) | $4.39 | — |
| Shweetz No-Bake Chocolate 3pk | $1.49 | — |
| Shweetz No-Bake Peanut Butter 3pk | $1.49 | — |
| Shweetz Muddy Bites Cup | $4.39 | — |
These are highly indulgent, making them perfect as desserts or shareable snacks.
🎂 Cake Pops, Cupcakes & Premium Desserts
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| iNKLES Birthday Cake Pop | $2.39 |
| iNKLES Chocolate Cake Pop | $2.39 |
| iNKLES Cookies N Cream Cake Pop | $2.39 |
| Kimberley’s Chocolate Filled Cupcake | $3.89 |
| Kimberley’s Red Velvet Filled Cupcake | $3.89 |
| Kimberley’s Vanilla Filled Cupcake | $3.89 |
| Funfetti Cake Parfait | $3.99 |
🍰 Classic Cakes & Bakery Favorites
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| David’s Brookie (3.5oz) | $2.19 |
| David’s Chocolate Chip Brownie | $2.19 |
| Killer Brownie Chocolatier | $2.49 |
| Killer Brownie Kitchen Sink | $2.49 |
| Nemo’s Banana Cake | $2.29 |
| Nemo’s Carrot Cake | $2.29 |
| Nemo’s Chocolate Bundt Cake | $2.29 |
| Nemo’s Coffee Cake | $2.29 |
| Nemo’s Orange Dreamswirl Cake | $2.29 |
| Nemo’s Strawberry Cake | $2.29 |
🥧 Toaster Tarts, Pound Cakes & European Treats
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| My Mother’s Apple Strudel | $2.29 |
| Cinnamon Toaster Tart | $2.29 |
| Raspberry Toaster Tart | $2.29 |
| Prairie City Iced Lemon Pound Cake | $2.19 |
| Prairie City Sea Salt Caramel Butter Cake | $1.99 |
| Rip Van Wafels Caramel & Vanilla | $1.69 |
| Rip Van Wafels Snickerdoodle | $1.69 |
More from Sheetz:
🧃 Best Value Bakery Items at Sheetz
| Budget Pick | Price |
|---|---|
| MTgo! Soft Pretzel | $1.29 |
| No-Bake Dessert 3pk | $1.49 |
| Rip Van Wafels | $1.69 |
| Killer Brownies | $2.49 |
⭐ Most Popular Sheetz Bakery Picks
- Shweetz Gourmet Cookies
- Donut Holes Cups
- Cinnabon Muffins
- Killer Brownies
- Nemo’s Cakes
These items consistently rank highest for taste, freshness, and value.
If you are interested in other items check out our full blog section with All Sheetz Menus and Full Sheetz Menu With Prices.
📍 Are Bakery Prices the Same at Every Sheetz?
Prices may vary slightly by location, region, and promotions.
Most bakery items fall between $1.29 and $4.99, making Sheetz one of the most affordable convenience-store bakeries.
🧠 Why the Sheetz Bakery Menu Is So Popular
- Fresh, soft, bakery-quality desserts
- Wide selection for every craving
- Budget-friendly pricing
- Perfect pairing with coffee & drinks
- Available 24/7 at most locations
❓ FAQs – Sheetz Bakery Menu
Does Sheetz bake items fresh daily?
Many Shweetz items are prepared fresh and restocked regularly, while branded desserts arrive pre-packaged.
Are calorie counts available?
Some items list calories, but values may vary by batch and portion size.
Can I order bakery items online?
Yes. Most bakery items are available through Sheetz online ordering and in-store pickup.
🔍 Final Verdict
The Sheetz bakery menu with prices proves that convenience stores can compete with specialty bakeries. Whether you want a $1 snack, gourmet cookie, rich brownie, or breakfast pastry, Sheetz delivers quality, variety, and value — anytime, anywhere.