If you’re craving fast, customizable, made-to-order meals, the Sheetz MTO Menu (Made-to-Order Menu) stands out as one of America’s favorite convenience-food experiences. Whether you’re stopping at a Sheetz location during a late-night road trip, grabbing lunch between meetings, or ordering delivery, the Sheetz MTO Menu brings restaurant-style customization to a gas-station convenience store — at prices that almost feel too good to be true.
In this guide, we break down everything you need to know about the Sheetz MTO Menu, including:
- Top best-selling meal categories
- Full customization options
- Calories & nutrition insights
- Prices and portion sizes
- What to order first (beginner picks)
- FAQs + ordering tips
👉 Also read: Sheetz Nutrition Guide
👉 Compare: Is Sheetz Gas Top Tier?
What Is the Sheetz MTO Menu?
MTO stands for Made-To-Order, meaning every item is created fresh only after you place your order — in-store, at the self-order kiosks, or online via the Sheetz app. Instead of pre-packaged sandwiches, the Sheetz MTO Menu acts like an all-day customizable food bar — burgers, subs, dogs, wings, steak sandwiches, appetizers, combos, seasonal options, and more.
🥤 It’s like fast-food meets Subway-style customization — but Sheetz lets you choose everything from bread to spreads to toppings.
Top Picks From the Sheetz MTO Menu (Most Popular Items)
Here are the fan-favorite and highest-selling items based on ordering trends and Sheetz menu structure:
| Item | Starting Price | Calories (Base) |
|---|---|---|
| Made-To-Order Burger | $4.99 | 221 cals |
| Classic Sampler (Choice of 3 Appz) | $6.00 | Variable |
| Shwingz | $7.39+ Half | 533+ cals |
| Steak Sandwich / Wrap | $5.69+ | 311+ cals |
| Italian Sub | $5.69+ | 344+ cals |
| Turkey Sub | $4.89+ | 307+ cals |
| Made-To-Order Hot Dog | $1.00+ | 140 cals |
Now let’s break each category down…
Made-To-Order Burger — Best Value on the Sheetz MTO Menu
Starting at: $4.99
Base calories: 221
Why it stands out: Extreme customization + optional premium extras
When it comes to Sheetz MTO Menu highlights, the burger is a #1 fan pick. Beginning at just $4.99, you customize EVERY layer:
🥯 Choose Your Bread (1 Required)
| Bread Option | Cal |
|---|---|
| Traditional Bun | 156 |
| Tortilla Wrap | 300 |
| Sliced Sourdough | 235 |
| Croissant (+$0.70) | 190 |
| Plain Bagel (+$0.70) | 260 |
| Everything Bagel (+$0.70) | 300 |
| Waffle (+$0.70) | 722 |
| Pretzel Roll (+$0.70) | 220 |
| 🔹 No Bread — low-carb option | 0 |
🧀 Add Cheese (Up to 2)
American, Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Nacho Cheese, Provolone, Shredded Cheese, Swiss (+$0.60 each)
🥫 Choose Spreads (Any!)
Ketchup, Mustard, Mayo, Ranch, Boom Boom, Buffalo Garlic Blitz, BBQ, Marinara, Honey Mustard, Jalapeño Ranch, Golden BBQ, Teriyaki, Sour Cream & more
🥗 Free Toppings
Shredded Lettuce, Tomatoes, Relish, Pickles, Red Onion, Jalapeños, Diced Onion, Salsa, Mild Pepper Rings
🍖 Premium Extras
| Extra | Add-On | Cal |
|---|---|---|
| Bacon | +$1.20 | 115 |
| Brisket | +$3.00 | 352 |
| Pepperoni | +$1.60 | 212 |
| Double Meat | +$2.50 | 221 |
Ordering Tip: Most customers add Boom Boom Sauce + Bacon + Pretzel Roll for the ultimate flavor.
Classic Sampler — Best Appetizer Choice on the Sheetz MTO Menu
Starts at: $6.00
Calories: 0 base, customizable
If you can’t choose just one appetizer — Sheetz says: why choose? take three!
This combo lets you mix 3 different snacks in one box, making it a go-to for late-night cravings and group orders.
🍟 Pick Any 3 Apps (Required)
Wisconsin Cheese Bitez (331 cals)
Mac N’ Cheese Bitez (187 cals)
Mozzarella Sticks (209 cals)
Boneless Bitez (228 cals)
Onion Petalz (189 cals)
🌶 Add Shake Seasoning
Ranch Dust, Cajun Kick, Nacho Cheeze, Voodoo Seasoning, Old Bay (+$0.30 each)
🥣 Choose 1-2 Dippers
Ketchup, Nacho Cheese, Marinara, Ranch, Jalapeño Ranch, Garlic Sauce, Bleu Cheese, Honey Mustard, Boom Boom, Sour Cream, Buffalo Sauce & more
💡 Best combo recommendation:
Mac N’ Cheese Bitez + Mozzarella Sticks + Onion Petalz + Boom Boom + Voodoo Seasoning
Shwingz — Sheetz Wings Takeover
Half-Dozen: $7.39 — 533 cals
Dozen: $14.29 — 1,065 cals
The Sheetz Shwingz on the MTO Menu are crispy, juicy, customizable and served in 6- or 12-count portions.
Flavor Shakers (Choose 1)
Voodoo Seasoning, Ranch Dust, Cajun Kick, Nacho Cheese, Old Bay
Sauce / Dipper (Choose 1)
Ranch, Garlic Sauce, Bleu Cheese, Buffalo, Boom Boom, Golden BBQ, Honey Mustard, Tangy Teriyaki, Buffalo Garlic Blitz, Shweet & Sour, Nacho Cheese & more
Extra Dippers (+$0.70)
Ideal for people who LOVE sauce — Jalapeño Ranch, Boom Boom, Garlic Sauce, Bleu Cheese, Ranch, etc.
Steak Sandwich — Protein-Packed Favorite
Price: Starts $5.69
Calories: 311+ (Half) / 324+ (Sandwich) / 389+ (Wrap)
A warm steak hoagie or wrap, customizable just like the burger — but perfect if you want a softer bite and more protein.
⚡ Best for people who want something heavier than a sub but lighter than wings
Italian Sub — Classic Deli Flavor
Price: Starts $5.69
Calories: Half 344 / Whole 566 / Wrap 422
Italian lovers choose this for its blend of meats + customizable bread and toppings, making it a great lunch driver pickup item.
Turkey Sub — Best Healthy Pick on the Sheetz MTO Menu
Starts at: $4.89 (Half)
Calories: Half 307 / Whole 614 / Wrap 385
If you’re calorie-watching — this is the menu winner.
Pair with:
- Shredded lettuce
- Pico
- Mustard
- No-cheese option
…and you can keep the meal under 400 calories.
Made-To-Order Hot Dog — The $1 Legend
Starts at: $1.00
Calories: 140 (base)
This is the cheapest food item on the entire Sheetz MTO Menu — and you can still customize it like a premium item.
Bun Choices
Pretzel Bun (+$0.70, 152 cal)
Classic Hot Dog Bun (118 cal)
Cheese Add-Ons (+$0.60 each)
American, Pepper Jack, Swiss, Shredded Cheese, Nacho
Spreads & Toppings
Ketchup, Mustard, Mayo, Ranch, Boom Boom, Marinara
Tomatoes, Relish, Chili (+$0.60), Jalapeños, Sautéed Onions (extra), Sour Cream, Guacamole, Sauerkraut, Pico, Salsa
💡 Best cheap combo:
Hot Dog + Boom Boom Sauce + Diced Onions + Jalapeños = $1.50 total 🔥
How to Order From the Sheetz MTO Menu (Step-by-Step)
1️⃣ Walk inside, skip the cashier
2️⃣ Go to a touchscreen kiosk
3️⃣ Tap your category (Burgers, Dogs, Subs, Appz)
4️⃣ Customize every layer
5️⃣ Add to cart
6️⃣ Pay at the kiosk or register
7️⃣ Wait for your name to be called
✔ Ordering is fastest using the Sheetz App (recommended for rewards)
Drinks & Add-Ons to Pair With Your MTO Order
Although these are not in Sheet MTO Top Picks, top drink combos include:
- Sheetz Smoothies
- MTGo energy bottled drinks
- Lemonade slushies
- Freshly brewed coffee
- Fountain soda refills
💰 Best Ways to Save on the Sheetz MTO Menu
✔ Download Sheetz App — occasional BOGO on burgers & shwingz
✔ Sign up for Sheetz Rewards — earn fuel points
✔ Order combos instead of singles
✔ Choose turkey sub instead of steak for calorie + cost savings
✔ Add sauces yourself at condiment station where available
Leave a Reply