A great dipping sauce is the difference between a good MTO order and a great one. Sheetz knows this — which is why they’ve built a dedicated Extra Dipperz section into the MTO kiosk rather than treating sauces as an afterthought. You can add individual sauce portions to any order, mix and match across items, and build your own dipping sauce lineup at checkout. This page covers the complete Sheetz Extra Dipperz menu: every available sauce, price, calorie count, and the best pairings for each sauce across the MTO menu. Prices are auto-updated.

What Is Sheetz Sauce?

Sheetz Sauce is the chain’s proprietary house condiment — think of it as their version of a ‘secret sauce.’ It’s tangy, slightly sweet, and creamy, sitting somewhere between Thousand Island dressing and a Big Mac sauce with more tang. It’s the most versatile sauce on the Sheetz menu and works well with almost any MTO item — burgers, chicken, fries, and sandwiches especially.

It’s available as a dipping sauce through Extra Dipperz and can also be applied directly to any MTO item during the customization step at no extra charge (when used as a topping). Ordering it as a separate dipping sauce portion is the move when you want extra.

Best Sauce Pairings by Food Type

Food Item	#1 Sauce	#2 Sauce	#3 Sauce
Beef Burger	Sheetz Sauce	Chipotle Mayo	BBQ
Crispy Chicken Sandwich	Honey Mustard	Buffalo	Ranch
Grilled Chicken	Honey Mustard	Chipotle Mayo	Ranch
Chicken Tenders	Ranch	Honey Mustard	Buffalo
Hot Dog / Bratwurst	Spicy Brown Mustard	Queso	Sheetz Sauce
Pizza Flatz	Ranch	Buffalo	Marinara
Fries (plain)	Sheetz Sauce	Ranch	Ketchup
Loaded Fries	Sour Cream	Ranch	Sriracha
Mozzarella Sticks	Marinara	Ranch	—
Jalapeño Poppers	Ranch	Blue Cheese	—
Pretzel Bites	Queso	Spicy Brown Mustard	—
Nachos	Sour Cream	Guacamole	Sriracha
Burrito / Bowl	Sour Cream	Guacamole	Sriracha
Salad	Ranch	Blue Cheese	Honey Mustard

Low-Calorie Sauce Options at Sheetz

If you’re watching calories but still want flavour, these are the best lower-calorie dipping sauce choices:

• Yellow mustard — 5–10 cal per portion. The lowest calorie sauce option. Use generously without the guilt.
• Sriracha — 10–20 cal per portion. Adds serious heat for virtually no calories.
• Ketchup — 20–30 cal. A sensible pick when you just need a basic dipping sauce.
• Marinara — 30–50 cal. Great for mozzarella sticks or pizza flatz without the calorie hit of a creamy sauce.
• Buffalo sauce — 40–60 cal. Delivers bold flavour at a low calorie cost — one of the best calorie-to-impact ratios on the list.

How to Add Extra Dipperz to Your Sheetz Order

• At the MTO kiosk, after selecting your food items, navigate to the ‘Extras’ or ‘Add-Ons’ section.
• Select ‘Extra Dipperz’ to see the full available sauce list for your location.
• Add individual portions — you can add multiple different sauces to a single order.
• Each portion is priced separately, typically $0.49–$0.99.
• Through the Sheetz app, Extra Dipperz are added in the same ‘Extras’ section during checkout.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

What dipping sauces does Sheetz have?

Sheetz dipping sauces include ranch, honey mustard, BBQ, buffalo, Sheetz sauce, chipotle mayo, blue cheese, queso, sriracha, marinara, spicy brown mustard, ketchup, yellow mustard, sour cream, and guacamole. Availability varies by location — the kiosk will show what’s available at your store.

What is Sheetz sauce?

Sheetz sauce is the chain’s proprietary house condiment — tangy, slightly sweet, and creamy. It’s one of the most versatile sauces on the menu and works well with burgers, chicken, fries, and sandwiches. It’s available as a direct topping during MTO customization or as a separate dipping portion through Extra Dipperz.

How much do Sheetz dipping sauces cost?

Extra Dipperz dipping sauces at Sheetz are typically priced $0.49–$0.79 per portion, with premium options like guacamole running $0.69–$0.99. See the live price table on this page for current pricing.

Does Sheetz have ranch dipping sauce?

Yes. Ranch is one of the most popular dipping sauces at Sheetz and is available through the Extra Dipperz section of the MTO kiosk. It pairs particularly well with chicken tenders, jalapeño poppers, pizza flatz, and fries.

Does Sheetz have queso?

Yes. Sheetz queso (cheese sauce) is available as an Extra Dipperz sauce option, typically paired with pretzel bites, nachos, loaded fries, and hot dogs. It’s priced slightly higher than other sauce options at some locations.

Does Sheetz have honey mustard?

Yes. Honey mustard is a standard Extra Dipperz option at Sheetz — one of the most popular sauce pairings for chicken tenders, chicken sandwiches, and onion rings.

Does Sheetz have guacamole?

Yes. Guacamole is available as an Extra Dipperz add-on and as a direct topping on MTO items (burritos, burrito bowls, wraps, and burgers). It typically carries a small upcharge of $0.69–$0.99.