Sheetz Made to Order — known as MTO — is what sets Sheetz apart from every other convenience store chain. While competitors serve pre-wrapped sandwiches sitting under a heat lamp, Sheetz lets you build your food exactly how you want it at a touchscreen kiosk, and have it prepared fresh in minutes.

This page is your complete guide to the Sheetz MTO food menu: every major category, what’s worth ordering, how the customization system works, and what to expect on price and calories.

What Is the Sheetz MTO System?

MTO stands for Made to Order. It’s Sheetz’s in-store fresh food program, operated via self-service touchscreen kiosks at every store. You browse the menu, select your base item, then customize every component — bread, protein, toppings, sauces, temperature — before confirming your order.

Your order prints to a kitchen ticket, staff prepare it fresh, and your name or number is called when it’s ready. The whole process typically takes 3–8 minutes depending on how busy the store is.

Available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week at all Sheetz locations — including holidays. This is one of the key reasons Sheetz MTO has built such a loyal following: late-night cravings, early morning commutes, and everything in between are covered.

Tip: You can also order MTO through the Sheetz app for pickup, skipping the kiosk. App orders sometimes include exclusive deals not available at the kiosk.

Browse by sub-category

Tips for Getting the Most Out of MTO

• Use the Eat Shmart filter if you’re watching calories — it surfaces lower-cal options across all categories.
• Check the Values Menu first if you’re on a budget. Several full-size sandwiches are available for under $4.
• Customize proteins freely — most items allow you to swap the default protein for grilled chicken, extra beef, or plant-based options.
• Save your favorites in the Sheetz app to reorder quickly without going through the kiosk.
• Late-night ordering (midnight–5am) can be slightly faster since stores are less busy.

Sheetz MTO vs. Competitors

Feature	Sheetz MTO	Wawa	Casey’s
24/7 hot food	Yes	Most locations	Yes
Touchscreen ordering	Yes	Yes	Limited
Full customization	Yes	Yes	Limited
Breakfast all day	Yes	Yes	No
Mobile app ordering	Yes	Yes	Yes
Avg. wait time	3–8 min	3–8 min	2–5 min

Frequently Asked Questions

What does MTO stand for at Sheetz?

MTO stands for Made to Order. It refers to Sheetz’s fresh food program where everything is prepared after you place your order at an in-store kiosk or via the Sheetz mobile app.

Is Sheetz MTO available 24 hours?

Yes. The MTO system operates 24 hours a day, 7 days a week at all Sheetz locations, including holidays.

Can you order Sheetz MTO online or through the app?

Yes. The Sheetz mobile app (iOS and Android) allows you to order MTO items for in-store pickup. You can browse the full menu, customize, pay, and skip the kiosk line.

How long does a Sheetz MTO order take?

Most MTO orders are ready within 3–8 minutes. Wait times may be longer during peak hours. Late-night and early-morning orders are typically faster.

Does Sheetz MTO have vegetarian or vegan options?

Yes. The MTO menu includes several vegetarian-friendly options in the Eat Shmart, Saladz, and MexAmerican categories. Customization also allows you to remove meat from most items.

What is the cheapest thing on the Sheetz MTO menu?

The Sheetz Values Menu contains items priced under $4. Specific prices are listed on the Values Menu page on this site.

Are Sheetz MTO calories listed?

Yes. Calorie counts are displayed for every item and customization on the MTO kiosk and in the Sheetz app. Sub-category pages on this site also list calorie information alongside prices.