Explore the Create Your Own Shake menu at Sheetz. See current prices, calories, and customizable options below.
Prices verified September 7, 2026 — sourced directly from the Sheetz ordering system
📊 Category Insights: There are currently 9 items available on the Create Your Own Shake menu. Prices range from $4.59 to $5.19. Calorie counts reach up to 803 cals for the richest selections.
💡 Quick Menu Highlights & Food Hacks
- Most Affordable: Create A Shake Blue Raspberry ($4.59)
- Premium Choice: Create A Shake Cookiez-n-Cream ($5.19)
- Lowest Calorie: Create A Shake Banana (367 cals)
- 💰 Bang for Your Buck: Create A Shake Black Raspberry provides 175 calories per dollar (803 cals for 4.59).
🚨 30-Day Price Watch: We detected recent price changes in this category. Create A Shake Blue Raspberry went from $4.69 to $4.59. Create A Shake Cherry Vanilla went from $4.69 to $4.59. Create A Shake Banana went from $4.69 to $4.59.
| Item Details | Price | Calories | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
 Create A Shake Blue Raspberry Options  Mango +$1.99 Blue Raspberry +$1.99 Cherry +$1.99Options  Whipped Cream Peanut Butter +$0.49 | $4.69+$4.59+ ↓ | 617 cals | Customize |
 Create A Shake Cherry Vanilla Options  Dark Chocolate +$0.69 White Chocolate +$0.69Options Mango +$1.99Blue Raspberry +$1.99Cherry +$1.99Options  Immunity Support +$1.00 Sugar Free Glacier Energy 1 Pump +$0.79Sugar Free Glacier Energy 2 Pumps +$1.39Sugar Free Glacier Energy 3 Pumps +$1.89 Hydration +$1.00Options Whipped Cream | $4.69+$4.59+ ↓ | 745 cals | Customize |
 Create A Shake Banana Options  Regular +$4.59 Large +$5.59Options  Caramel +$0.49 Marshmallow +$0.49Sugar Free Caramel +$0.49 Sugar Free Vanilla +$0.49Vanilla +$0.49 Black Raspberry +$0.49 Blue Raspberry +$0.49 Cherry +$0.49Options  Brownie Bites +$1.00 Cookiez-n-Cream Bitz +$1.00 Reese's PB Cups +$1.00Options Immunity Support +$1.00Sugar Free Glacier Energy 1 Pump +$0.79Sugar Free Glacier Energy 2 Pumps +$1.39Sugar Free Glacier Energy 3 Pumps +$1.89Hydration +$1.00Options Mango +$1.99Blue Raspberry +$1.99Cherry +$1.99Options Whipped CreamPeanut Butter +$0.49 | $4.69+$4.59+ ↓ | 367 cals | Customize |
 Create A Shake Black Raspberry Options Regular +$4.59Large +$5.59Options Dark Chocolate +$0.69White Chocolate +$0.69Options Immunity Support +$1.00Sugar Free Glacier Energy 1 Pump +$0.79Sugar Free Glacier Energy 2 Pumps +$1.39Sugar Free Glacier Energy 3 Pumps +$1.89Hydration +$1.00Options Mango +$1.99Blue Raspberry +$1.99Options Whipped Cream | $4.69+$4.59+ ↓ | 803 cals | Customize |
 Create A Shake Cookiez-n-Cream Options Regular +$5.19Large +$6.19Options Caramel +$0.49Marshmallow +$0.49Sugar Free Caramel +$0.49Sugar Free Vanilla +$0.49Vanilla +$0.49Black Raspberry +$0.49Blue Raspberry +$0.49Cherry +$0.49Options Brownie Bites +$1.00Cookiez-n-Cream Bitz +$1.00Reese's PB Cups +$1.00Options Immunity Support +$1.00Sugar Free Glacier Energy 1 Pump +$0.79Sugar Free Glacier Energy 2 Pumps +$1.39Sugar Free Glacier Energy 3 Pumps +$1.89Hydration +$1.00Options Mango +$1.99Blue Raspberry +$1.99Cherry +$1.99Options Whipped CreamPeanut Butter +$0.49 | $5.19+$5.19+ ↓ | 367 cals | Customize |
 Create A Shake ChocolateMade with Ghiradelli® Options Regular +$4.59Large +$5.59Options Caramel +$0.49Marshmallow +$0.49Sugar Free Caramel +$0.49Sugar Free Vanilla +$0.49Vanilla +$0.49Black Raspberry +$0.49Blue Raspberry +$0.49Cherry +$0.49Options Brownie Bites +$1.00Cookiez-n-Cream Bitz +$1.00Reese's PB Cups +$1.00Options Immunity Support +$1.00Sugar Free Glacier Energy 1 Pump +$0.79Sugar Free Glacier Energy 2 Pumps +$1.39Sugar Free Glacier Energy 3 Pumps +$1.89Hydration +$1.00Options Mango +$1.99Blue Raspberry +$1.99Cherry +$1.99Options Whipped CreamPeanut Butter +$0.49 | $4.69+$4.59+ ↓ | 589 cals | Customize |
 Create A Shake Peanut Butter Options Regular +$4.59Large +$5.59Options Caramel +$0.49Marshmallow +$0.49Sugar Free Caramel +$0.49Sugar Free Vanilla +$0.49Vanilla +$0.49Black Raspberry +$0.49Blue Raspberry +$0.49Cherry +$0.49Options Brownie Bites +$1.00Cookiez-n-Cream Bitz +$1.00Reese's PB Cups +$1.00Options Immunity Support +$1.00Sugar Free Glacier Energy 1 Pump +$0.79Sugar Free Glacier Energy 2 Pumps +$1.39Sugar Free Glacier Energy 3 Pumps +$1.89Hydration +$1.00Options Mango +$1.99Blue Raspberry +$1.99Cherry +$1.99Options Whipped CreamPeanut Butter +$0.49 | $4.69+$4.59+ ↓ | 367 cals | Customize |
 Create A Shake Strawberry Options Regular +$4.59Large +$5.59Options Caramel +$0.49Marshmallow +$0.49Sugar Free Caramel +$0.49Sugar Free Vanilla +$0.49Vanilla +$0.49Black Raspberry +$0.49Blue Raspberry +$0.49Cherry +$0.49Options Brownie Bites +$1.00Cookiez-n-Cream Bitz +$1.00Reese's PB Cups +$1.00Options Immunity Support +$1.00Sugar Free Glacier Energy 1 Pump +$0.79Sugar Free Glacier Energy 2 Pumps +$1.39Sugar Free Glacier Energy 3 Pumps +$1.89Hydration +$1.00Options Mango +$1.99Blue Raspberry +$1.99Cherry +$1.99Options Whipped CreamPeanut Butter +$0.49 | $4.69+$4.59+ ↓ | 539 cals | Customize |
 Create A Shake Vanilla Options Regular +$4.59Large +$5.59Options Caramel +$0.49Marshmallow +$0.49Sugar Free Caramel +$0.49Sugar Free Vanilla +$0.49Vanilla +$0.49Black Raspberry +$0.49Blue Raspberry +$0.49Cherry +$0.49Options Brownie Bites +$1.00Cookiez-n-Cream Bitz +$1.00Reese's PB Cups +$1.00Options Immunity Support +$1.00Sugar Free Glacier Energy 1 Pump +$0.79Sugar Free Glacier Energy 2 Pumps +$1.39Sugar Free Glacier Energy 3 Pumps +$1.89Hydration +$1.00Options Mango +$1.99Blue Raspberry +$1.99Cherry +$1.99Options Whipped CreamPeanut Butter +$0.49 | $4.69+$4.59+ ↓ | 510 cals | Customize |