Fish at a convenience store sounds like a recipe for disappointment. Sheetz’s fish menu is the exception. Built on the same MTO made-to-order system as every other food category, the Sheetz fish items are cooked fresh after you order — not pre-fried and sitting in a warmer.
The lineup covers six distinct items across different formats: a classic fish sandwich, a hybrid hot dog-style fish roll, street tacos, a po’boy, a fully customizable fish option, and a full fish and chips platter. Prices and calories below are sourced directly from Sheetz menu data.
📊 Category Insights: There are currently 6 items available on the Fish menu. Prices range from $3.99 to $11.99. Calorie counts reach up to 1141 cals for the richest selections.
💡 Quick Menu Highlights & Food Hacks
- Most Affordable: Dockside Seadog ($3.99)
- Premium Choice: Fish & Chips Platter ($11.99)
- Lowest Calorie: Dockside Seadog (386 cals)
- 💰 Bang for Your Buck: Fish Sammie provides 137 calories per dollar (685 cals for $4.99).
| Item Details | Price | Calories | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
 Fish Options  Half +$5.99 Whole +$11.98 Sandwich +$4.99 Wrap +$5.99Options  White Sub Roll Pretzel Roll Flatbread Honey Wheat Seasoned Stuffing Roll No BreadOptions  Fryz +$1.60 Mozzarella Sticks +$2.30 Mac & Cheese Bites +$2.30 Fried Egg - On top of your sandwich +$0.70 Jalapeño Fryz +$1.50 Onion Petalz +$1.20Options  American +$1.00 Cheddar +$1.00 Pepper Jack +$1.00 Provolone +$1.00 Shredded Cheese +$1.00 Swiss +$1.00 Nacho Cheese +$1.00 Shredded Mozzarella Blend +$1.00 White Cheddar Cheese +$1.00Options  Tartar Sauce Ketchup Yellow Mustard Mayonnaise Marinara Dr. Pepper BBQ BBQ Sauce Boom Boom Sauce Buffalo Sauce Caesar Honey Mustard Italian Ranch Jalapeno Ranch Olive Oil & Vinegar Buffalo Garlic Blitz Tangy Teriyaki Golden BBQOptions  Crispy Onions +$0.50 Cranberry Orange Relish +$0.50 Gravy +$0.50 Cooked Onions & Peppers +$0.70 Caramelized Onions +$0.50 Guacamole +$0.70 Shredded Lettuce Cooked Peppers +$0.50 Pickles Red Onions Diced Onions Tomatoes Mild Pepper Rings Nacho Cheeze Seasoning +$0.30 Jalapenos Pico +$0.60 Sour Cream +$0.80 Cream Cheese +$0.80 Pepper Ranch Dust Seasoning +$0.30 Chili +$0.80 Cajun Kick Seasoning +$0.30 Salsa Old Bay Voodoo Seasoning +$0.30 Salt ParmesanOptions  Bacon +$1.20 Pepperoni +$1.00 | $4.99+$4.99+ ↓ | 473 cals | Customize |
 Fish SammieBun, Fried Fish, American Cheese, Shredded Lettuce, Tartar Sauce Options  Yes please No Thanks | $4.99+ | 685 cals | Customize |
 Dockside SeadogHot Dog Bun, Fried Fish, Mayo, Pico | $3.99 | 386 cals | Order Now |
 Fish Street Tacos Options  2 Pack +$7.99 3 pack +$9.99Options Nacho Shredded CheeseShredded Mozzarella BlendWhite CheddarOptions BBQ Sauce Taco SauceTartar SauceBoom BoomRanchBuffalo SauceJalapeno RanchSalsaSour CreamOptions PicoShredded LettuceDiced OnionsJalapenosMild Pepper RingsRed OnionsGuacamoleTomatoes | $7.99+$7.99+ ↓ | 457 cals | Customize |
 Fish Po'BoyWhite Sub Roll, Fried Fish, Mayo, Cajun Seasoning, Sliced Tomato, Shredded Lettuce Options Yes PleaseNo Thanks | $7.99+ | 585 cals | Customize |
 Fish & Chips Platter5 Pieces Fried Fish, Fryz, Tartar Sauce Options BBQ SauceKetchupDr. Pepper BBQRanchHoney MustardBuffalo SauceTangy Teriyaki Garlic SauceGolden BBQBuffalo Garlic BlitzBoom BoomJalapeno RanchYellow MustardNacho CheeseWhite Cheddar CheeseOptions BBQ Sauce +$0.60Buffalo Sauce +$0.60Nacho Cheese +$0.60Ranch +$0.60Garlic Sauce +$0.60Dr. Pepper BBQ +$0.60Yellow Mustard +$0.60 Shweet & Sour +$0.60Tangy Teriyaki +$0.60Golden BBQ +$0.60Boom Boom +$0.60Jalapeno Ranch +$0.60Honey Mustard +$0.60Buffalo Garlic Blitz +$0.60Ketchup +$0.60White Cheddar Cheese +$0.60 | $11.99+ | 1141 cals | Customize |
Sheetz Fish Menu: Nutrition Comparison
| Item | Price | Calories | Protein (est.) | Best For |
| Dockside Seadog | $3.99 | 386 cals | 18–22g | Lightest, cheapest, on-the-go eating |
| Fish Street Tacos | $7.99+ | 457 cals | 20–25g | Freshest flavour profile with toppings |
| Fish (customizable) | $4.99+ | 473 cals | 20–26g | Custom builds, calorie control |
| Fish Po’Boy | $7.99 | 585 cals | 24–28g | Most restaurant-style, Cajun flavour |
| Fish Sammie | $4.99 | 685 cals | 22–26g | Classic fish sandwich format |
| Fish & Chips Platter | $11.99 | 1,141 cals | 48–60g | Sharing, large appetite, full meal |
Sheetz Fish vs. Fast Food Fish Sandwiches
| Sheetz Fish Sammie | McDonald’s Filet-O-Fish | Wendy’s Fish Fillet | Popeyes Fish Sandwich | |
| Price | $4.99 | $5.99 | $6.49 | $5.99 |
| Calories | 685 cals | 400 cals | 490 cals | 635 cals |
| Includes cheese | Yes (American) | Yes (American) | No | No |
| Made to order | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| 24/7 availability | Yes | Many | Some | Some |
When Is the Sheetz Fish Menu Available?
Unlike some chains that only serve fish items during Lent, Sheetz’s fish menu is available year-round at all locations. All fish items are made to order through the MTO system and are accessible 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. There are no time restrictions or seasonal limitations on the fish menu.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Sheetz have fish?
Yes. Sheetz has a dedicated fish menu with 6 items: a customizable fried fish base ($4.99+), Fish Sammie ($4.99), Dockside Seadog ($3.99), Fish Street Tacos ($7.99+), Fish Po’Boy ($7.99), and Fish & Chips Platter ($11.99). All are made to order and available 24/7.
How much is a fish sandwich at Sheetz?
The Sheetz Fish Sammie is $4.99 (685 calories). The customizable fish base starts at $4.99. The Dockside Seadog is $3.99 (386 calories) — the cheapest fish item. The Fish Po’Boy is $7.99. See the price table on this page for the full current pricing.
Does Sheetz have a fish sandwich?
Yes. The Sheetz Fish Sammie ($4.99, 685 cals) is a classic fish sandwich with fried fish, American cheese, shredded lettuce, and tartar sauce on a bun. There’s also a fully customizable fish option and the Fish Po’Boy for a more elevated build.
What is the Dockside Seadog at Sheetz?
The Dockside Seadog is a unique Sheetz fish item — a hot dog bun filled with fried fish, mayo, and pico de gallo. At $3.99 and 386 calories, it’s the cheapest and lightest item on the Sheetz fish menu, and the most portable format for eating on the go.
Does Sheetz have fish tacos?
Yes. Sheetz Fish Street Tacos are $7.99+ with 457 base calories. They’re made to order with full customization of toppings and sauces at the kiosk.
Does Sheetz serve fish year-round?
Yes. Unlike some fast food chains that only offer fish during Lent, Sheetz’s full fish menu is available year-round, 24/7, at all locations.
What is the Sheetz Fish & Chips Platter?
The Sheetz Fish & Chips Platter is $11.99 and includes 5 pieces of fried fish, Fryz, and tartar sauce — totaling 1,141 calories. It’s the largest fish item on the menu and the best value per piece of fish at $2.40 per fillet.