Explore the Protein Shakes menu at Sheetz. See current prices, calories, and customizable options below.
Prices verified September 7, 2026 — sourced directly from the Sheetz ordering system
📊 Category Insights: There are currently 28 items available on the Protein Shakes menu. Prices range from $3.19 to $6.89.
💡 Quick Menu Highlights & Food Hacks
- Most Affordable: Nesquik Chocolate Protein Power 14oz ($3.19)
- Premium Choice: Fairlife Core Power Elite Chocolate 42g Complete Protein 14oz ($6.89)
- 🥩 Top Protein Pick: Shamrock Rockin Protein Max Chocolate 19.7oz delivers 50g of protein at just $0.10 per gram.
🚨 30-Day Price Watch: We detected recent price changes in this category. Chobani Mixed Berry Vanilla 10oz went from $3.69 to $3.79. Chobani Mixed Berry Vanilla 10oz went from $3.79 to $3.69.
| Item Details | Price | Calories | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
 Shamrock Rockin Protein Max Chocolate 19.7oz50g Protein | $4.99 | — | Order Now |
 Shamrock Rockin' Protein Max Chocolate Banana 19.7oz50g Protein | $4.99 | — | Order Now |
 Shamrock Rockin' Protein Max Vanilla 19.7oz50g Protein | $4.99 | — | Order Now |
 Fairlife Core Power Elite Chocolate 42g Complete Protein 14oz42g Protein | $6.89 | — | Order Now |
 Fairlife Core Power Elite Strawberry 42g Complete Protein 14oz42g Protein | $6.89 | — | Order Now |
 Fairlife Core Power Elite Vanilla 42g Complete Protein 14oz42g Protein | $6.89 | — | Order Now |
 Chobani 30G Protein Mango 14oz30g Protein | $4.99 | — | Order Now |
 Chobani 30G Protein Strawberries & Cream 14oz30g Protein | $4.99 | — | Order Now |
 Chobani 30G Protein Vanilla Ice Cream 14oz30g Protein | $4.99 | — | Order Now |
 Shamrock Chocolate Rockin' Protein Builder 12oz30g Protein | $3.69 | — | Order Now |
 Shamrock Strawberry Rockin' Protein Builder 12oz30g Protein | $3.69 | — | Order Now |
 Shamrock Vanilla Rockin' Protein Builder 12oz30g Protein | $3.69 | — | Order Now |
 Fairlife Core Power Chocolate 26g Complete Protein 14oz26g Protein | $5.39 | — | Order Now |
 Fairlife Core Power Strawberry Banana 26g Complete Protein 14oz26g Protein | $5.39 | — | Order Now |
 Fairlife Core Power Vanilla 26g Complete Protein 14oz26g Protein | $5.39 | — | Order Now |
 Barebells Berry Milk Drink 11oz24g Protein | $4.19 | — | Order Now |
 Barebells Choco Milk Drink 11oz24g Protein | $4.19 | — | Order Now |
 Barebells Vanilla Milk Drink 11oz24g Protein | $4.19 | — | Order Now |
 Nesquik Chocolate Protein Power 14oz23g Protein | $3.19 | — | Order Now |
 RYSE Clear Protein Country Time Lemonade 16.9oz22g Protein | $3.99 | — | Order Now |
 RYSE Clear Protein Kool-Aid Tropical Punch 16.9oz22g Protein | $3.99 | — | Order Now |
 RYSE Clear Protein Strawberry Banana 16.9oz22g Protein | $3.99 | — | Order Now |
 Chobani Mixed Berry Vanilla 10oz20g Protein | $3.69$3.79 ↑ | — | Order Now |
 Chobani Strawberries & Cream 10oz20g Protein | $3.79 | — | Order Now |
 Spylt Caffeinated Chocolate Milk 11oz20g Protein | $4.49 | — | Order Now |
 Spylt Caffeinated Peanut Butter Chocolate 11oz20g Protein | $4.49 | — | Order Now |
 Spylt Caffeinated Cookies & Cream 11oz20g Protein | $4.49 | — | Order Now |
 Spylt Caffeinated Strawberry Milk 11oz20g Protein | $4.49 | — | Order Now |