Explore the Signature Milkshake Recipes menu at Sheetz. See current prices, calories, and customizable options below.
Prices verified August 18, 2026 ā sourced directly from the Sheetz ordering system
š Category Insights: There are currently 11 items available on the Signature Milkshake Recipes menu. Prices range from $4.69 to $6.49. Calorie counts reach up to 1989 cals for the most indulgent choices. Options are fully customizable on the touchscreen, allowing you to alter ingredients to fit your dietary needs.
š” Quick Menu Highlights
- Most Affordable: Peach Milkshake (4.69+)
- Premium Choice: Reese's Caramel Cup (6.49)
- Lowest Calorie: Peach Milkshake (524 cals)
| Item Details | Price | Calories | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
 Firewerkz ShakeVanilla Milkshake with Cherry Popping Bubblez, Blue Raspberry Syrup and Whipped Cream | 6.29 | 883 cals | Order Now |
 Cinnamon Roll | 5.49 | 707 cals | Order Now |
 Peach Milkshake Choose Your Size  Regular $4.69 Large $5.69 | 4.69+ | 524 cals | Customize |
 Peach Berry Milkshake Choose Your Size Regular $4.69Large $5.69 | 4.69+ | 860 cals | Customize |
 Peach Raspberry Milkshake Choose Your Size Regular $4.69Large $5.69 | 4.69+ | 888 cals | Customize |
 Peach Strawberry Milkshake Choose Your Size Regular $4.69Large $5.69 | 4.69+ | 808 cals | Customize |
 Sh'morezChocolate, Toasted Marshmallow and Graham Crumbs | 4.99 | 1205 cals | Order Now |
 Reese's Caramel CupMade With Reese'sĀ® | 6.49 | 1150 cals | Order Now |
 Caramel Fudge Brownie Blast Give Yourself a Boost?  Immunity Support $1.00 Sugar Free Glacier Energy 1 Pump $0.79Sugar Free Glacier Energy 2 Pumps $1.39Sugar Free Glacier Energy 3 Pumps $1.89 Hydration $1.00 | $5.49 | 1989 cals | Customize |
 Peanut Butter Lover Choose Your Size Regular $5.19Large $6.19 | 5.19+ | 979 cals | Customize |
 Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie | 5.49 | 1729 cals | Order Now |