Explore the Signature Recipes menu at Sheetz. View current prices, calories, and customization options.
Prices verified September 20, 2026 — sourced directly from the Sheetz ordering system
📊 Category Insights: There are currently 10 items available on the Signature Recipes menu. Prices range from $4.99 to $6.49. Calorie counts reach up to 1989 cals for the richest selections.
💡 Quick Menu Highlights & Food Hacks
- Most Affordable: Sh'morez ($4.99)
- Premium Choice: Reese's Caramel Cup ($6.49)
- Lowest Calorie: Cinnamon Roll (707 cals)
- 💰 Bang for Your Buck: Caramel Fudge Brownie Blast provides 369 calories per dollar (1989 cals for 5.39).
| Item Details | Price | Calories | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
 Cereal ChillerVanilla Milkshake with Fruity Pebbles® | $5.39 | 821 cals | Order Now |
 Pumpkin Pie Milkshake | $5.39 | 866 cals | Order Now |
 Chai Me Pumpkin Milkshake | $5.39 | 844 cals | Order Now |
 Peppermint Bark Milkshake | $5.39 | 797 cals | Order Now |
 Cinnamon Roll | $5.39 | 707 cals | Order Now |
 Sh'morezChocolate, Toasted Marshmallow and Graham Crumbs | $4.99 | 1205 cals | Order Now |
 Reese's Caramel CupMade With Reese's® | $6.49 | 1150 cals | Order Now |
 Caramel Fudge Brownie Blast | $5.39+ | 1989 cals | Customize |
 Peanut Butter Lover | $5.19+ | 979 cals | Customize |
 Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie | $5.39 | 1729 cals | Order Now |